AM BEST'S MONTHLY INSURANCE MAGAZINE
Best's Review
AM BEST'S MONTHLY INSURANCE MAGAZINE



Crafting Culture

Evan Greenberg, chairman and CEO of the new Chubb, discusses crafting a new corporate culture, finding direction and whether he's ready to take a breather from acquisitions.

"Culture," Evan Greenberg says.

He lets the word hang in the air. And in some respects, it has been hanging overhead for nearly a year.

Culture has been a critical issue, and a subject of much speculation, since Greenberg announced last July that his company, Ace, planned to acquire Chubb.

The acquisition brought together two giants of the property/casualty space. It also raised a giant question: Whose culture would prevail?

Greenberg hasn't spoken much publicly about how he plans to pull off one the largest insurance acquisitions in history. Not long ago, when asked which legacy company the new Chubb would resemble, Greenberg quipped that it would be Ace in Chubb's clothing.

Now, sitting in a conference room on the 45th floor of his Manhattan office, he is being asked how good a tailor he is. Because many, at least those watching from the outside, wonder whether those clothes will fit.

Greenberg gazes at the ceiling, briefly considering his response. He drops his eyes level and chooses his words deliberately.

"First of all, it is working," he says of the integration. "Secondly, people love to build intrigue around things. Everybody loves a good car accident, don't they? You turn on the television and what are the most popular shows? They're things that involve violence or sex. It's boring if it's all OK, so they need intrigue. And so I start with that, when I think about the outside-in and the pundits.

"I also listen to the outside and, generally, I'm listening to comments from people who haven't run anything. They have no organization management experience, and so it's easy to imagine when you don't have experience in fact to weigh you down. And I also know any good competitor likes to create a little mischief to get people going.

"So I hate to disappoint everybody, but I believe it's going to go quite well."

'This is on steroids'

Greenberg speaks with measured confidence. This isn't his first rodeo. Far from it. He's done 15 acquisitions in the last 15 years, culminating with the $29.5 billion deal to buy Chubb.

By this point, he's well practiced in spotting red flags. He can tell when integration is working. He can tell when it's not.

"I know how to judge it," he says.

But this isn't like the last 14 deals. This acquisition nearly doubled the size of his company. Chubb says it created the sixth-largest property/casualty insurer in the United States and the largest publicly traded, global property/casualty insurer. His new company has annual gross written premiums of $37.4 billion and assets of $154 billion. It has 31,000 employees spread across 54 countries.

By its very size and scope, this integration process isn't like the others.

"This is on steroids," Greenberg says.

But he's had 15 years of warmups to prepare. Ace's history of acquisitions has given Greenberg plenty of hands-on training in how to integrate two companies. Yes, this is different. Both the stage and the stakes are bigger. But many of the elements are the same. And experience has taught Greenberg some lessons.

He has his own best practices. Number one among them is, don't wait.

Greenberg began structuring the "new Chubb" before it was officially the new Chubb. The deal closed in January. By last fall, he had announced his executive team, named the heads of business lines and created his reporting structure. By December, 80% of employees in the United States knew whether they had a job, what that job was, and who they worked for.

"Because we have done this before, we were able to hit the ground running in July and do a total planning process, which is unheard of in acquisitions," he says. "Generally they start planning much later. For us, when we close, we are executing."

Greenberg compares the acquisition and integration process to surgery. You want to get on and off the operating table as quickly as possible.

"The longer you're on that table, more things can go wrong," he says. "An acquisition and the integration is the same thing. You've got to be well planned, very thoughtful. You've got to be able to measure where you are at any one time all along the way. And you want to get it done as quickly as possible.

"By the way, people want certainty; they want to know. Whatever the answer is, people can handle an awful lot. They just want to know."

'You need a new North Star'

Within three weeks of announcing his intention to acquire Chubb, Greenberg was hosting his first town hall meeting in the lobby of Chubb's Warren, N.J., headquarters. According to a transcript of the event filed with the SEC, he assured his future employees that Chubb's agency distribution system would remain intact and told them he planned to keep the Chubb name out of respect and admiration.

It wasn't simply the name he admired.

As he reflects back now, Greenberg speaks with great respect for what Chubb's people accomplished.

"People want to be led," he says. "And one of the things the Chubb culture was starving for was to be led. It was under-led and under-invested for a long time. It takes a certain culture to succeed and do well when you're under-invested and under-led. And they did so well with what they had."

Greenberg gets a bit exasperated when asked which culture will prevail. The question presumes a black-or-white answer, which is not the palette he paints with.

Chubb's new branding reflects the direction Greenberg is heading. Chubb no longer has a defined corporate color for its logo. Instead it has a palette of nine complementary colors, which Greenberg sees as a reflection of the company's diversity, optimism, energy and passion.

In the new look, the name Chubb stands alone as a single word. But it can appear in an array of bright hues, from lime green to purple to orange. On its website, in its advertising and even for employee business cards, Chubb uses the vibrant colors of its palette interchangeably.

"Your box of [business] cards is now like a box of Skittles," he says. "It's fabulous. I love it."

Rainbows symbolize the promise of a new beginning, and this is Chubb's new beginning. The new look is part of its new culture.

"When you think about culture, there are two [cultures] that everyone is leaving behind," Greenberg says. "And you need a new North Star."

'Culture is led'

One could argue Greenberg is Chubb's North Star.

Leadership and behavior are intertwined with culture, as Greenberg sees it. In its simplest form, he says, culture is defined by shared behavioral norms and shared experiences. The knitting together of that cultural fabric is an ongoing process.

"Culture is led," Greenberg says. "It is managed."

It is led and managed by him. His actions will craft the corporate culture.

He is well aware of that.

"People emulate the behaviors of their leaders," Greenberg says. "How you carry yourself, what's important to you, how you speak, the behaviors that you exhibit.

"It starts with me and my management team. They take cues and they'll emulate me. Their direct reports will emulate us, and so on. It cascades."

Greenberg stops short of saying which of his behaviors he'd like his staff to emulate. "I am a unique critter," he says with a smile.

But when he starts describing the broader characteristics of his company, it is clear that his personality is stamped all over it.

"People trade here on results, and getting it done, not simply a top down measure and accountability of that, but actually a horizontal accountability," he says. "Everyone holds everyone else accountable, and it's transparent that way.

"We are a frank organization. We're not rude. We're never demeaning. But we are frank with each other and we don't give each other cold comfort. We call it as we see it but on the positive, we are very supportive and encouraging. If there are issues or problems, it's simply to identify what they are and get on and correct them.

"We're not internally a political culture. It's about getting it done. And people are not provincial, so therefore we know when we work together we produce better results."

There is always room for improvement. Greenberg's intensity is matched only by his drive to get better.

"A hallmark of the culture is restlessness," he says. "We're restless characters. It can always be better. It always has more promise to fulfill than you've recognized."

'I couldn't be more optimistic'

The new Chubb is filled with promise. Greenberg won't give his competitors a roadmap to his strategy, but he says he is excited about the prospects he sees. "The opportunities in front of us are simply fabulous," he says. "I couldn't be more optimistic."

He feels the same optimism about the integration process.

"The organization is fitting together as well as I could imagine," he says. "I am not Pollyannaish. To put the two companies together--they're two great companies--stapling them together is the easy part.

"We're not out to staple them together. We're integrating them. I will know over the next two years or longer that our work on cultural integration is complete because I won't feel or observe in a micro way any meaningful pockets of difference."

The cultural gap between them, Greenberg is quick to point out, isn't as large as outsiders seem to think.

"One is more hierarchical, a little more layered, a little more bureaucratic and more customer oriented in certain ways," he says. "One is a bit more entrepreneurial, more informal. But both are very buttoned up in their decision making. Both are very thoughtful and deliberate in their processes. Both are underwriting companies, the two best underwriting companies in the industry. That's the hallmark of the wellhead.

"I'll tell you what, the hardest culture to build is an underwriting culture. They both have that. Their attention to excellence, their attention to detail, their attention to execution--so fabulous."

Greenberg describes his people as craftsmen, and the theme of craftsmanship runs through his vision for the new Chubb. Craftsmen, he says, demand excellence of themselves.

In many respects, he says, he found Ace and Chubb to be "quite similar." There are, however, some differences, many of which are borne of the differences in their businesses.

"One is fundamentally much more of an agency company; one is more of a brokerage company," he says. "By the nature of those two, your user interface is different."

Greenberg doesn't see those differences as deal-breakers to a successful blending.

"Not differences that create incompatibility," he says by way of explanation, "but differences that you pay attention to and make room for. You select the best of the differences, and you introduce an integrator."

Chubb, for example, was superior in its training and development capabilities. That's an area where Greenberg sees legacy Chubb leading the way.

"One of things we do just so well at legacy Chubb is the training program," Greenberg says. "It harks back to days gone by in insurance, where we would train professionals that way."

That's how Greenberg himself got his start in the business. He came up through AIG's legendary training program. He joined AIG in 1975 and rose up the ranks to become president and chief operating office under his father, former AIG CEO Maurice "Hank" Greenberg. He stayed with AIG for 25 years before joining Ace as its vice chairman in 2001.

"I was a product of those [training programs], as were a number of my colleagues," he says. "For the last seven years we endeavored to build that within Ace, and we've done pretty well, but it's not as well developed as what was in old Chubb. That's an area where there is going to be no cost reduction. That's where we're actually, if anything, going to invest more, because training and development, that's part of culture. That is an important area to us."

Claims service is another area where Chubb's culture is likely to prevail, though that could vary a bit by line.

"Ace has good claims service; Chubb is in a class of its own in terms of its reputation for service, for claims, engineering and loss control," Greenberg says. "Really that's an area where we're very focused. If anything the total organization will emulate and learn from that."

Particularly in its personal lines segment, where it is renowned for its high net worth niche, legacy Chubb had a reputation for outstanding claims handling. Chubb also had a strong commercial presence in the middle market, whereas Ace had more dominance in the large commercial space. One style of claims handling does not necessarily fit all.

"It comes back to brokerage versus agency, a middle market customer or personal lines customer versus a very complex large corporate [customer]," Greenberg says. "The skill set and the approach vary to a degree by the nature of that. And so what each does well, clearly we've identified and will preserve--and beyond preserve, nurture."

'Stay tuned'

The transition process is likely to take three years, all told. But Greenberg isn't thinking of it as a stop-and-start endeavor.

"Everything starts as a coat of paint," he says. "To get the ultimate out of it is iterative. It's a process. It's layers on layers on layers.

"It's a journey."

Six months after the deal closed, it's an all-consuming journey. Chubb is in the throes of integrating everything from its back-office functions to its front-line operations.

"My organization is completely absorbed and obsessed with getting on and executing," Greenberg says.

That means growing. Despite Ace's many acquisitions, two-thirds of its growth came organically, as did virtually all of Chubb's. Greenberg plans to keep that trend going. "We are business builders first," he says. "That's the focus."

But after 15 acquisitions in 15 years, one has to wonder whether Greenberg will keep that trend going as well.

A slight smile crosses his face.

"Stay tuned," he says.

Learn More

Chubb Corporation

A.M. Best # 058342

For ratings and other financial strength information visit

www.ambest.com.

by Kate Smith, senior associate editor, Best's Review



There’s So Much to Cover—Don’t Miss the Latest
Get more news stories like this delivered to your inbox by signing up for our article spotlights.

Subscribe

Back to Home