Best's Review


Transformation: Fraternals
Coming Together

Two Catholic fraternal benefit insurers joined forces to create a groundbreaking technology initiative that they hope will bring back-office efficiencies and lower costs for their organizations.
  • Lori Chordas
  • March 2020
  • print this page


Key Points

  • Tech Challenges: Fraternal insurers Catholic United Financial and Catholic Financial Life share a similar mission, philosophy and geography, but they also face similar limitations posed by their legacy platforms and outdated policy administration systems.
  • Partnership in Innovation: In a breakthrough in collaboration, the two fraternals launched a joint venture that will build next-generation technology to serve their members.
  • Wider Implications: The companies hope the technologies they develop may eventually be used by other fraternal insurers.


American author F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote in The Last Tycoon: “No brilliant idea was ever born in a conference room.”

But Timothy Kuzma, chairman of the American Fraternal Alliance, begs to differ.

Last year, two members of the alliance joined forces to create a groundbreaking technology initiative that Kuzma hopes will drive more innovation and collaboration in the fraternal market.

In August 2019, Catholic Financial Life and Catholic United Financial launched Conventus Now, a first-of-its-kind wholly owned initiative that will allow the two organizations to develop and share state-of-the-art technologies, placing them on a level playing field with their larger peers.

The idea for the joint venture was born out of a discussion at a 2017 investment conference—something Kuzma calls “a revolutionary meeting of the minds.”

As the leaders of the two fraternal organizations sat across the table from each other discussing the opportunities and struggles their companies faced, “it became evident pretty quickly that the biggest challenge we share is technology,” said Harald Borrmann, CEO, president and board chairman of Catholic United Financial.

Like many fraternals, his company struggled to keep up with the big guys when it came to technology.

For years the Arden Hills, Minnesota-based fraternal benefit society, often feeling disadvantaged by its size, made do with tools such as a 20-year-old policy administration system and other antiquated technologies.

But when it became evident those tools were no longer sufficient, Borrmann and his management team knew they needed to devise a way to develop and fund the use of new technologies for their life insurance and annuity products to remain competitive with their peers.

Three hundred miles away in Milwaukee, another Catholic-focused fraternal, Catholic Financial Life, faced similar struggles.

“We also had a legacy platform and a two-decade-old policy administration system in constant need of updating that was limiting our ability to improve the service experience for our members and advisers,” said William O'Toole, CEO and president of the fraternal founded in 1868.

Fraternals have long been challenged by technology and the limited budgets and resources needed to fund those tools.

High initial implementation costs and the rapid pace of technological change can be particularly daunting for small and midsized fraternals.

And fraternal societies of all sizes often struggle to keep up with larger traditional insurers who can easily manage long-term road maps with ongoing innovation and implementation and upgrade processes connecting their direct-to-consumer channels and portals to their back offices, according to the October 2019 Best's Market Segment Report, U.S. Fraternals Face a Difficult Growth Environment.

As a result, fraternals left searching for other options to compete are often forced to outsource technology and back-office services to control and shrink expenses.

William O’Toole Catholic Financial Life

Don’t count out fraternals. We’re here to stay, and we hope collaborations like Conventus Now will bring even more attention to the fraternal market and drive more innovation in our sector.

William O’Toole
Catholic Financial Life

Fulfilling a Need

Outsourcing back-office functions was an idea Borrmann and O'Toole quickly tossed aside.

Instead, they wanted to keep those services in-house and create a vehicle through which their companies can develop and operate technology solutions.

The goal of their novel joint initiative, Borrmann said, is to modernize new business and in-force operations with next-generation technologies to lower customer acquisition costs and achieve economies of scale to benefit members.

“During our initial conversation three years ago, it became very clear that we have many similarities, including a shared philosophy, products and geography,” he said.

“But we also share the same struggles with our back-office systems and proposed time frame to find something new to improve our tech needs. So we knew we needed to work together to come up with a collaborative way to approach technology,” Borrmann said.

The first step in that process was devising an end-to-end solution where sales reps can sit down with prospective members to fill out applications, underwrite them, administer policies and pay claims.

“We also want to give our members things that we might not otherwise be able to afford to give them on our own, and create the look and feel of a much larger organization in terms of quality and depth of what members can get from the experience without losing the personal touch,” Borrmann said.

Catholic United and Catholic Financial Life then searched for a technology partner that could join in the Conventus Now initiative to help streamline the servicing of members' needs, open new sales channels and lower ownership costs, O'Toole said.

Last summer they selected cloud-based software provider iPipeline. The two fraternals plan to use iPipeline's omnichannel SSG Digital Platform with a next-generation policy administration system to automate and simplify new and existing individual life and annuity business, plus drive digital transformation and collaboration within their organizations.

Joining Forces

Collaboration was the impetus behind Conventus Now and its name.

The word “conventus” means “coming together” in Latin. “We added the word 'now” to emphasize that the project is here and now is the time,” Catholic United Financial's Borrmann said.

For years the American Fraternal Alliance has been trying to drive greater collaboration among fraternals.

“One of the biggest benefits of the fraternal model is the nature of fraternals' mission of social good that can lead to collaboration,” Kuzma said.

Fraternal benefit societies were created in the 1800s to assist immigrants coming to America. Since then, they've developed into nonprofit, mutual aid organizations that insure members and their families against death, disease and disability.

“Conventus Now is the kind of collaborative breakthrough we've been looking for, and it's a perfect example of what fraternals can do when they put their minds together,” said Kuzma, who along with leading the alliance's board is the president and CEO of Polish Falcons of America, a fraternal provider of life insurance and financial services to members of the nation's Polish community.

Edward Kohlberg, a director at AM Best, credits the mission and goals shared by Catholic Financial Life and Catholic United Financial as laying the foundation for what he hopes will drive down costs for the companies and become a quantum leap in innovation in the fraternal market.

“They're both Catholic fraternal organizations dedicated to providing financial stability to their members, and that will help with shared costs for services, software, marketing and other needs,” he said.

The two fraternals have been serving U.S. Catholics and their families since the latter half of the 19th century.

Today, Catholic Financial Life, the second largest Catholic not-for-profit financial services organization in the nation, serves nearly 140,000 members in 28 states. Fraternal benefit association Catholic United Financial offers life insurance, annuities and retirement products to more than 75,000 members in Minnesota, North Dakota, South Dakota, Wisconsin and Iowa.

Both companies have more than $1 billion in assets. Catholic Financial Life's total assets now surpass $1.6 billion, and last year Catholic United Financial celebrated a milestone when its assets hit the $1-billion mark. Assets have grown as the amount of insurance in-force, both life and annuities, have grown. The fraternals return revenues each year to members and communities through dividends, charitable contributions and fraternal benefits after operating expenses are paid and conservative reserves are set aside to recognize future liabilities.

Harald Borrmann Catholic United Financial

We share the same struggles with our back-office systems and proposed time frame to find something new to improve our tech needs. So we knew we needed to work together to come up with a collaborative way to approach technology.

Harald Borrmann
Catholic United Financial

The Road Ahead

The goal of Conventus Now is to shed member costs and technology expenses. But Borrmann and O'Toole hope the joint venture will also help grow membership for their organizations.

Membership in fraternal societies has been on a downward trajectory in recent years, largely driven by a shrinking middle market and less focus on the fraternal community, said David Marek, a financial analyst at AM Best.

“Today younger generations prefer to socialize online rather than socializing at a fraternal chapter or lodge,” he said.

Over the years, many fraternals have loosened their requirements in an effort to expand membership, broadening their target market to include more religious affiliations or demographic groups, according to AM Best's fraternal market report.

Also in recent years, relatively flat premium growth, limited financial resources, a changing landscape and size have made it difficult for many fraternals to become first movers on innovation and stay relevant in the market—a market Marek characterizes as “challenged.”

But he's hopeful that collaborative efforts like Conventus Now will drive innovation back into the fraternal market and become a model other fraternals can follow.

“They may look at it and ask, 'What can we do to partner with other fraternals to create something similar or other kinds of breakthroughs,'” American Fraternal Alliance's Kuzma said.

He's also bullish on the idea that Conventus Now could one day be used by other fraternals.

“But we don't want to put the cart before the horse,” Catholic United Financial's Borrmann said.

“First we have the responsibility to benefit our members and our two societies. Then after passing that litmus test, the technology we develop could possibly be shared with other fraternals in the future,” he said.

Last year, Catholic Financial Life and Catholic United Financial spent much time strategizing and building Conventus Now.

This year is all about execution and implementation, Borrmann said.

“Our goal in 2020 is to create a plan, work that plan and test how it works. Then later in the year, we'll begin to roll out and implement aspects of Conventus in our companies and hopefully drive more appeal to the fraternal market, which is well-poised for growth,” he said.

Catholic Financial Life's O'Toole offers his own take on the future of the market and Conventus Now with an analogy synonymous to the city in which he works.

“Sitting here in Milwaukee, there was a period of time when the major breweries were dominant players in their market. Today, you have microbreweries in just about every city or town in the country.”

He compares fraternals to those specialized breweries. “Twenty years ago people discounted the rise of microbreweries and said they'd only drink major brand beers. But the world has changed, and there's now a taste for both types of beers. I think there's also still a taste of what fraternals' missions are all about and where profits are directed toward our missions and members and not to enrich directors and shareholders.

“We believe our taste still matters to people and will resonate with them, especially millennials. So don't count out fraternals. We're here to stay, and we hope collaborations like Conventus Now will bring even more attention to the fraternal market and drive more innovation in our sector,” O'Toole said.

Lori Chordas is a senior associate editor. She can be reached at

Back to Home

Want More News From Best's Review?

Sign up for our Best's Review Newsletter and we'll send you featured news stories straight to your inbox.