Best's News


Best’s News & Research Service - September 20, 2002 11:08 AM (EDT)

Swiss Re CEO to Be Deposed in World Trade Center Case

    print icon

NEW YORK //BestWire// - The leaseholder of the World Trade Center, battling in court with 20 insurers over whether the terrorist catastrophe that destroyed the center should count as one loss or two, is looking to an unlikely source to bolster its case: the chief executive of Swiss Reinsurance Co., the lead insurer on the property.

Silverstein Properties has won the right to depose Walter B. Kielholz, managing director and chief executive officer of Swiss Re, to explore statements Kielholz made recently in London, said Gerald McKelvey, a spokesman for Silverstein. In a speech, Kielholz said Swiss Re viewed the World Trade Center's twin towers as "two separate towers," McKelvey said.

U.S. District Judge John S. Martin Jr. ruled Sept. 19 that Silverstein had a right to depose Kielholz in light of the statements.

"We'll have a chance to draw him out on that," McKelvey said. It's significant because Swiss Re has argued that the destruction of the property should be considered one insured event, worth a maximum of $3.55 billion, while Silverstein has argued it should count as two insured events, worth $7.1 billion.

Jacques Dubois, chairman of Swiss Re America, said Silverstein is "grasping at straws."

"Our position is entirely consistent-that a single coordinated attack destroyed a single insured property," Dubois said.

He said Kielholz's statements have been misconstrued. Also, he said Kielholz was speaking without a written speech, and Swiss Re isn't sure who made the transcript of Kielholz's speech.

Twenty-two insurers took a piece of liability on the property, but two of them have already settled out of court.

Separately, Martin reserved his decision on a request from five of the 20 remaining insurers involved in World Trade Center litigation that would like to be dropped from the debate. The insurers-Allianz Insurance, Hartford, Royal Indemnity, St. Paul and Zurich American-are seeking summary judgment in the case. They argue their circumstances are different from other insurers involved in the litigation and that they clearly wrote the coverage based on a single occurrence.

Because no formal policy was in place on Sept. 11, the lawsuit is based on the language used in a binder form, an initial document that described insurance terms and conditions. Silverstein and the insurers disagree on which binder form was used. Swiss Re, which is responsible for 22% of the liability on the twin towers and Nos. 4 and 5 World Trade Center, said it bound itself on the basis of a policy form provided by Willis Group Holdings Inc. called WilProp 2000. That form specifies that "occurrence shall mean all losses or damages that are attributable directly or indirectly to one cause or to one series of similar causes. All such losses will be added together and the total amount of such losses will be treated as one occurrence irrespective of the period of time or area over which such losses occur."

Silverstein's attorneys argue that coverage was bound by a Travelers form, which they said didn't define "occurrence." Silverstein could use that lack of definition to argue that two planes hitting two towers should count as two claims, or $7.1 billion instead of $3.55 billion.

In February, two of the insurers agreed to settle claims by paying $365 million. Ace Bermuda Insurance Ltd., a subsidiary of Ace Ltd. (NYSE:ACE), agreed to pay $298 million, and XL Insurance (Bermuda) Ltd., a unit of XL Capital Ltd. (NYSE:XL), agreed to pay $67 million, for a total of $365 million (BestWire, Feb. 15, 2002). The two Bermuda insurers were the only participants in the insurance program that had signed binders expressly referencing the WilProp form, Silverstein has said.
(By Meg Green, senior associate editor, BestWeek: Meg.Green@ambest.com)



Property And Liability Insurers Property Insurance Reinsurance September 11 Terrorism Reinsurers International Catastrophes


Latest News

More from Best’s News


Trending


    


2
BEST'S CREDIT RATING ACTION
AM Best Revises Outlooks to Positive for AmTrust Group’s Members
Oct 14, 2026 09:36 AM (EDT)


4
HOMEOWNERS INSURANCE
State Farm, Allstate Plan to Reopen to New Homeowners Business in California
Sep 21, 2026 12:40 PM (EDT)