Briefing: Agreement With Switzerland Boosts China's WTO Standing
- BR Unassigned
- November 2000
-
China and Switzerland concluded a bilateral trade agreement that eventually will allow three Swiss insurers to offer their services in the Chinese market-and that leaves China just one agreement shy of having all the bilateral accords it needs for accession to the World Trade Organization.
Although the agreement doesn't specify which companies will be authorized to set up in China, the beneficiaries are expected to be Zurich Financial Services, Swiss Life Insurance & Pension Co. and Swiss Reinsurance Co. The three insurers have applied for licenses to enter the Chinese nonlife, life and reinsurance markets, respectively. The only Swiss insurer currently licensed to operate in China is Winterthur.
Under the terms of the agreement, China will offer one operating license to a Swiss nonlife insurer before China's WTO accession. The two remaining licenses, for a life insurer and a reinsurer, will be offered within a short period after China formally enters the WTO.
The European Union concluded a bilateral trade agreement with China in May that netted a commitment from Beijing to offer seven new insurance licenses before China's WTO accession. Swiss negotiators pressed their Chinese counterparts to offer four licenses for their insurers with immediate effect.
U.S. officials also have been putting the heat on the Chinese to deliver insurance licenses. In a letter dated Sept. 5, U.S. Commerce Secretary Norman Mineta called on Beijing to provide seven new operating licenses to U.S. insurers before China joins the WTO. Mineta noted that the EU now has 11 insurance licenses, compared with four existing or promised licenses for U.S. insurers.
Insurers Shrug Off Euro's Woes
The relentless fall of the euro has shaken money markets, but seems to be having little effect on the bottom line for insurers whose business crosses the Atlantic.
European insurers that do a lot of business in dollars are getting a boost to their earnings when those premiums are translated back into euros, the new common currency of the European Union. Conversely, claims payments in dollars take a bigger bite out of underwriting results. U.S. insurers, meanwhile, face an opposite effect when their euro-dominated policies are converted into dollars.
But equity analysts have said the euro's woes aren't weighing heavily on insurers from either side of the Atlantic. It's a greater problem for manufacturing companies than for insurers, analysts agreed.
Andrew Ritchie, an analyst with Fox-Pitt, Kelton in London, said the weak euro could have a hypothetical effect on European insurers' expansion plans in the United States, but in practice that doesn't seem to be the case. The currency's fall against the dollar "doesn't seem to be affecting the corporate calendar," Ritchie said.
U.S. insurers are seeing similarly muted effects on their European business, said Michael Lewis, an analyst with UBS Warburg in New York. He said companies, such as Chubb Corp., are seeing some effect on their premiums but not on earnings.
"The bottom-line effect is not that big," said Simon Foessmeier, an analyst with Bank Julius Baer in Frankfurt, Germany.
Midwest Drought Feeds Crop Insurance Sales
Crop insurers in the Midwest are in a potentially difficult situation as farmers load up on insurance for the winter wheat crop they are planting in drought-parched fields.
Despite dusty conditions and low expectations, farmers in Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas and Nebraska are planting southern winter wheat. They also are insuring higher percentages of their crop in anticipation of poor growing results and with the help of a new law that provides significantly higher federal subsidies this year for crop insurance.
The new federal law expands subsidies for both multiple-peril crop insurance and crop-revenue insurance. A farmer insuring 50% of his crop would have received a 57% subsidy from Washington for multiple peril under the old law, but will get 67% under the new one. For crop-revenue insurance, the subsidy rises to 67% from 41% for 50% coverage. Farmers can insure up to 85% of their crop.
Despite the dry conditions and high demand for crop insurance, insurers cannot raise prices for the coverage. The federal government regulates prices, adjusting them up or down based on experience.
While the higher subsidies may put insurers at risk of larger claims, government participation in the crop-insurance markets helps over the long haul. Insurers are willing to write the higher coverages for several reasons, said Art Barnaby, agricultural economist at Kansas State University. One is that they are partially reinsured by the government, particularly at catastrophic levels.
GAO: Regulatory Weaknesses Gave Frankel an Opportunity
Weaknesses in insurance regulation and oversight contributed to Martin Frankel's alleged $200 million fraud going undetected for years, according to a report by the federal General Accounting Office.
Those weaknesses were found at the state level and with certain support services at the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Circumstances surrounding the scandal were unusual enough to raise questions beyond those asked in a routine examination, the GAO said. "The answers, or in some cases, lack of answers, to those questions could have resulted in a much earlier exposure of the scam," the report states.
Three key aspects of regulatory oversight were found to be weak: change of ownership approval; routine financial analysis; and on-site examinations.
The GAO report cites, for example, "inadequate due diligence" performed on the buyer application. "In the case of the Thunor Trust, the money to purchase the first insurance company was supposedly provided by three individuals or grantors," the report said. "However, during our review of change in ownership application data, we found no evidence that state regulators sought financial information from the grantors to validate their financial condition despite the trust's dependence on the grantors for funds."
Limited sharing of information among state insurance regulators also contributed to the atmosphere that allowed Frankel's scam to spread, the GAO said.
The GAO conducted its review in states where the principal insurers connected with the scam were domiciled-Tennessee, Mississippi, Missouri, Oklahoma and Arkansas-as well as in Virginia, Alabama, New York, Illinois and Connecticut.
N.J. Passes Bill Allowing Patients to Sue HMOs
The New Jersey Senate passed legislation that would allow patients to sue their health maintenance organizations.
An identical bill is in the New Jersey Assembly's health committee. If the Assembly passes an identical bill, it moves on to the governor for her signature.
The Senate's Health Care Carrier Accountability Act states that since carriers are in many instances making medical decisions when they deny, delay or diminish heath-care treatments, carriers should be held to the same level of legal responsibility as doctors and other health-care providers who make decisions regarding the necessity and appropriateness for medical care. The legislation applies to health and dental benefits plans.
"It is fair and appropriate that insured patients have the opportunity to dispute carrier or organized delivery system decisions in court, as well as in internal- and external-appeals procedures," the legislation reads in part.
Gov. Christie Whitman commended the Senate for providing patients with the right to sue HMOs, but she said the legislation is not broad enough. The right to sue should be given to any aggrieved party who has sent a claim to binding arbitration but remains unsatisfied, Whitman said in a statement.
Turning the health-care system over to lawyers is a very bad idea, said Susan Pisano, spokeswoman for the American Association of Health Plans. "We take very seriously, and are very respectful of patients having recourse," Pisano said, "but we don't think recourse and suing are the same things."
Access to the courts would be restricted to cases that meet one of seven different criteria or problems, ranging from a covered person's death to physical or mental harm.
Losses From Ohio Tornado Reach Catastrophe Level
Insurers will see at least $33.1 million in insured losses from a tornado that tore through Xenia, Ohio, and surrounding areas Sept. 20, the Ohio Insurance Institute said. This makes the storm a catastrophe-that is, any event that causes more than $25 million in insured losses and affects many insurers.
Insurers are reporting at least 4,071 insured claims from the storm, according to the institute. Three out of every four claims reported so far involve homeowners or renters insurance. The rest were for damaged or totaled autos.
Dick Luedke, spokesman for State Farm Group, said the insurer estimates it has about 750 claims totaling about $8 million on homeowners policies, and about 250 other claims totaling $750,000 statewide, in the wake of a series of severe storms.
The worst damage is in the town of Xenia, about 15 miles southeast of Dayton in western Ohio, Luedke said. A tornado ripped through the town Sept. 20, killing one resident, injuring at least 80 and destroying 48 homes, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported.
Nationwide Group's catastrophe director, Jane Teach, said the company is projecting $3.5 million in storm-related costs across Ohio. Teach said there are about 450 claims pending, but that total could go as high as 1,200.
Ohio Tornado Claims
Insurers can expect at least $33.1 million in damages from the tornado that hit Xenia, Ohio, on Sept. 20.
Company Estimated Claims Losses
State Farm Ins. Cos. 1,000 $8,750,000
Cincinnati Ins. Cos. 165 8,000,000
Nationwide Ins. 1,200 3,500,000
Western Reserve Group 125 1,500,000
Grange Ins. Cos. 300 750,000
Motorists Ins. 125 700,000
Farmers Ins. Group 111 469,500
American Family Ins. Group 55 200,000
Central Mutual Ins. Co. 50 125,000
Buckeye Mutual Ins. Group 6 41,500
EMC-Hamilton Mutual Ins. Co. 5 10,000
Source: Ohio Insurance Institute