Leaving It For Tomorrow
Retirement products vary widely across Asia, where market demand is especially strong.
Distinct social and economic conditions are shaping a diverse pension market across the Asia-Pacific region, where high consumer-savings rates have spurred insurers to develop more products designed for retirement.
At the same time, uncertain economic conditions and varying levels of regulatory involvement present risks for life insurers that want to enter these markets.
Asian consumers not only have the highest uptake of pension and investment products worldwide, but also the greatest number of potential first-time buyers. About 33% of Asian consumers have plans to make first-time purchases within a year, according to a regional survey by U.K.-based Aviva plc. More than 87% of consumers have savings products--almost 20% more consumers than in the United States and Europe.
Business development in most Asian markets focuses on savings protection to support retirement. Longevity insurance and annuity products are emerging in mature markets like Japan and Australia, driven by demand for post-retirement pension protection.
Recent pension reforms in the region are mainly designed for accumulation of retirement savings through defined contribution plans. Government-sponsored compulsory schemes, such as Australia's superannuation, Hong Kong's Mandatory Provident Fund and Singapore's Central Provident Fund have created significant opportunities for life insurers in managing those funds.
But for post-retirement annuity and longevity insurance products, "pension reforms have had much less of an impact in Asia," said Lawrence Tsui, director of life and health at Swiss Re. Reform efforts, to make mandatory the allocation of a portion of retirement savings as an annuity or pension, are absent. So, too, are efforts to promote such actions through taxes and other incentives, he said.
Insurers' business focus has largely been on traditional life and health products with a savings feature. But growing pension assets and an aging demographic have created demand for annuity and longevity insurance, said Michael Sherris, professor of actuarial studies at the University of New South Wales and president of the Asia-Pacific Risk and Insurance Association.
Even for Japan's developed system, with almost universal protection through national pension plans, the country still finds pension assets inadequate to support retirement, medical and nursing care for a population with long life expectancy. This creates great potential for insurance solutions for post-retirement protection, said Neil Katkov, senior vice president, Asia, at consultancy Celent.
Annuity Development
Government policy in the areas of pension reform and tax-benefits support is crucial to encourage private promotion of longevity and life annuity insurance, according to Sherris. But few government efforts have been initiated in pension reform for the post-retirement phase.
Most market activity has been in Japan and Singapore, where variable annuities feature guaranteed minimum lifetime withdrawal benefits, Tsui said. The global financial crisis resulted in significant losses for insurers, leading to a cessation of sales of variable annuities.
In a prevailing low interest rate environment, Tsui said, "locking in an interest rate for the rest of one's life is not a particularly attractive proposition." So, consumers defer annuity purchases because of low interest rates and instead look for shorter-term annuity products, Sherris said.
Both western and emerging markets have few risk-management and hedging tools available for longevity risk, said Tsui. In the United Kingdom, the world's largest annuity market, most longevity risk has been passed to reinsurance. Life reinsurers see this as an opportunity to diversify their portfolio by taking some longevity risk.
Transfer of longevity risk to capital markets is limited. Capital markets still see longevity as a novel risk and require a premium for taking such risks. Tsui said recent activity suggests that reinsurers are better able to offer competitively priced longevity risk than the capital markets.
Taking Shape
The Asia/Pacific region had €1.85 trillion (US$2.6 trillion) in combined retirement assets under management in 2009, according to Allianz. The region lost 10.2% of assets between 2007 and 2008, with mature markets like Japan and Australia taking major losses. However, emerging Asian markets reported a 17% increase in assets.
"Looking ahead, emerging markets in Asia will develop most dynamically," said Bruce Bowers, chief executive of Asia Pacific at Allianz. Pension assets in emerging Asia are expected to grow by 16.8% a year, reaching €2.2 trillion by 2020.
Increasing wealth in emerging markets will further fuel retirement savings, Bowers said. Traditionally, retirement income in Asia has come from family support. New pension systems introduced by governments to support changing demographic and economic conditions will boost accumulation of pension assets in Asia.
Most countries will see a higher savings rate aimed at stronger retirement protection. While growth potential for life insurance "is still far from exhausted," Bowers sees interest in variable annuity products constantly increasing.
Allianz offers several savings-related products for retirement protection across Asia, including variable annuities and unit-linked insurance in Taiwan and South Korea, as well as various life products.
A number of Australian life insurers have launched longevity products with a guaranteed minimum lifetime withdrawal benefit. Japan is seeing signs of a comeback in variable annuities. Mature markets like Japan and Australia are not expected to see a higher growth rate for pension assets than emerging markets.
Mature Markets' Status
Among the pension and longevity growth markets in the Asia-Pacific region, the two most mature markets--Japan and Australia--also offer growth potential, albeit with a heavier dose of innovation.
Australia and Japan are the two largest Asian pension markets, each accounting for more than 3% of global retirement assets. Emerging Asian markets only represent 1.8% of global funds, according to a report by insurer Allianz SE.
The two countries have been ahead of the rest of the region in the development of retirement and longevity protection markets. Japan is still predominated by the defined-benefit scheme despite some discussion of the defined-contribution system.
"Australia…introduced a mandatory defined contribution scheme in 1992 and is often seen as a role model for the region," noted Allianz in its report.
In Japan, setbacks in the variable annuity market related to the global financial crisis are driving insurers to develop new products based on assets such as bonds rather than equity, Celent's Katkov said. Japanese consumers provide strong demand for investment products, and more young people are seeking pension products to support themselves after retirement, he said.
This huge demand contributed to robust annuity business after the deregulation of bancassurance for annuity products in 2002. Foreign insurers brought in variable annuities through bancassurance channels, driven by high commission incentives. The fixed annuity market also expanded after the launch of variable annuity products.
At least 26 life insurers were selling variable annuities in Japan prior to the financial crisis, according to a report from consultancy Towers Watson. About 80% of market share was held by the six largest annuity underwriters: Hartford Life, Mitsui Sumitomo MetLife, Sumitomo Life, ING Life, Tokio Marine Nichido Financial Life and Manulife Life. (The financial crisis prompted the withdrawal of Hartford Life and ING Life from Japan's variable annuity market.)
These annuity products often offer guaranteed return at a rate significantly above risk-free interest rates so as to meet consumers' need for post-retirement protection with a decent investment yield. In the long run, Tsui said, these products may not be sustainable.
"It's generally true that annuity products have not been particularly popular across Asia," said Tsui. This is true in most countries, apart from nations like the United Kingdom, which has a compulsory policy for partly allocating retirement assets in pensions or annuities, he noted.
Drivers of Innovation
Australia may see a change from a commission-based intermediary system to fee-based services with a focus on professional advisers in financial planning.
Katkov said the same trend is seen in Japan, where insurers are focusing more on customer-oriented services rather than sales-driven product promotion.
In Japan, many variable annuity insurers have discontinued sales of high-risk products, replacing them with products with lower guarantees.
Katkov said life insurers there are shifting to simpler, safer and more easily managed products like fixed-annuity products. Foreign-currency-denominated annuity products are also being promoted by some insurers in Japan.
Reinsurance has been a more popular tool to diversify minimum-guarantee risk than setting up a hedging portfolio in Japan. However, reinsurance availability has been limited and premiums are sometimes expensive, according to a report by consultancy Towers Watson.
Under Australia's superannuation system, pension assets continue to grow, particularly as the government plans to increase the compulsory contribution rate to 12% from 9%. Australia was among the fastest-growing pension markets between 1999 and 2009, with a 10.4% rise in pension assets, according to Towers Watson.
Tsui said insurance vehicles available for superannuation assets after retirement are very limited. Although the market sees some movement toward development of variable annuity-type solutions, Tsui noted it will be difficult for private insurers to develop anything in the absence of government support.
"One key risk factor for private insurers in this environment is that they do not push themselves too far in searching for a longevity protection solution that people are willing to buy," Tsui said.
Learn More:
Allianz Societas Europaea
A.M. Best Company # 85014
Distribution: Company agents, bancassurance
Swiss Re Group
A.M. Best Company # 85010
Distribution: Reinsurance brokers
For ratings and other financial strength information visit www.ambest.com.
By Iris Lai, Hong Kong bureau manager: Iris.Lai@ambest.com