Auditors & Actuaries
Top Audit and Actuarial Firms — 2021 Edition
Ranked by loss reserves. Special Section sponsored by Johnson Lambert.
- Best's Review Staff
- December 2021
-
The Auditors and Actuaries Special Section is sponsored by Johnson Lambert.
Best's Review presents its ranking of the top auditors and actuaries.
These rankings focus on independent accountants who audit an insurer's annual financial statements and on third-party actuaries who provide an annual statutory actuarial opinion regarding an insurer's policy and claim reserves. These listings of auditor and actuarial firms include only insurance companies with statements that listed auditors or external actuaries. The insurer population includes U.S. and Canadian companies that file with AM Best.
Unlike the annual statutory audit, for which the insurer must use an independent certified public accountant, the actuarial opinion may be provided by an internal actuary, which is an actuary directly associated with the insurer. The data are derived from individuals or firms in the context of providing an annual audit or actuarial opinion. Many of the individuals or firms listed in the tables are likely to have additional insurance clients for which they perform a variety of other services, but such services are not reflected in this survey's data.
The primary task of audit firms working with insurance companies is to certify the audits of financial statements. That means they must understand statutory-based financial accounting. They also stay abreast of developments among regulatory bodies, particularly the National Association of Insurance Commissioners in the United States, to ensure compliance with current standards.
Rankings for both the auditing and actuarial firms are based on the loss reserves held by their client insurance companies. Again, as described in the methodology, not all insurers are included, and not all client relationships between insurance companies and their auditing and actuarial firms have been reflected.
For property/casualty insurers, loss reserves are the total of loss and loss adjustment expense reserves.
For health insurers, loss reserves are the sum of:
1. Claims unpaid, less reinsurance ceded.
2. Accrued medical incentive pool and bonus amounts.
3. Unpaid claims adjustment expense.
4. Aggregate health policy reserves.
5. Property/casualty unearned premium reserves.
6. Aggregate health claim reserves.
For life insurers, loss reserves are the sum of:
1. Aggregate reserves for life and for accident and health.
2. Liabilities for deposit type contracts.
3. Life policy and contract claims.
Count for each sector (P/C, life and health) includes companies for which an auditor or actuary was listed on the statements of companies designated in that sector, plus where they were listed by other companies that also had reserves of that sector's type. For example, some companies designated as health carriers report P/C loss reserves in addition to health reserves; those companies are included in the count for the P/C sector, in addition to being included in the client count for the health sector.
Actuary Firm – 2021 Edition
P/C Loss Reserves (US$000)
Actuary Firm |
P/C Loss
Reserves
(US$000) |
P/C
Count |
PricewaterhouseCoopers |
53,907,868 |
83 |
Beneficial Consultants |
46,948,502 |
7 |
Ernst & Young |
43,778,471 |
97 |
KPMG |
38,187,859 |
63 |
Milliman |
34,352,411 |
146 |
Willis Towers Watson |
30,207,178 |
141 |
Deloitte |
11,985,762 |
36 |
TMNA Services |
6,434,760 |
6 |
Regnier Consulting Group |
4,090,366 |
54 |
Pinnacle Actuarial Resources |
2,826,232 |
53 |
Merlinos & Associates |
1,881,545 |
84 |
Perr & Knight |
1,060,543 |
41 |
The Actuarial Advantage |
936,409 |
14 |
Christopher Gross Consulting |
936,345 |
1 |
Streff Insurance Services |
892,129 |
29 |
Central Actuarial Solutions |
761,350 |
7 |
Oliver Wyman |
737,246 |
17 |
Kufera Consulting |
724,042 |
33 |
FTI Consulting |
711,894 |
4 |
Actuarial Advisors |
574,412 |
15 |
EVP Advisors |
513,611 |
19 |
Lewis & Ellis |
474,697 |
23 |
Enstar |
473,520 |
3 |
LWCC |
453,599 |
1 |
SG Risk |
445,290 |
9 |
Constellation |
366,320 |
2 |
Source: AM Best data and research
Actuary Firm – 2021 Edition
Life Loss Reserves (US$000)
Actuary Firm |
Life Loss
Reserves
(US$000) |
Life
Count |
Milliman |
23,087,789 |
20 |
PricewaterhouseCoopers |
14,633,326 |
8 |
Lewis & Ellis |
8,128,222 |
43 |
Miller & Newberg |
7,486,472 |
22 |
Allen Bailey & Associates |
7,267,694 |
11 |
Griffith Ballard & Company |
7,251,007 |
14 |
Guggenheim Insurance Services |
6,145,075 |
1 |
Willis Towers Watson |
5,838,920 |
7 |
RGA Enterprise Services |
2,903,825 |
2 |
Actuarial Resources Corporation |
2,879,059 |
8 |
Steimla & Associates |
1,269,557 |
5 |
Jeffrey D. Miller & Company |
1,237,933 |
1 |
Rudd and Wisdom |
1,148,073 |
28 |
Actuarial Management Resources |
896,879 |
7 |
Deloitte |
630,746 |
3 |
Hause Actuarial Solutions |
556,223 |
18 |
Wakely |
485,230 |
2 |
Bruce & Bruce Company |
463,307 |
1 |
Bruce & Associates |
420,431 |
1 |
Agee & Associates |
353,397 |
10 |
Everence Services |
291,690 |
2 |
CPS Actuaries |
274,948 |
11 |
DJOrr Consulting |
230,446 |
1 |
Davies Insurance Services |
170,475 |
1 |
KPMG |
123,296 |
1 |
Source: AM Best data and research
Actuary Firm – 2021 Edition
Health Loss Reserves (US$000)
Actuary Firm |
Health Loss
Reserves
(US$000) |
Health
Count |
Milliman |
5,640,946 |
105 |
Ernst & Young |
4,584,528 |
24 |
Lewis & Ellis |
1,955,408 |
20 |
Wakely |
1,500,286 |
32 |
Optum |
1,487,945 |
19 |
PricewaterhouseCoopers |
1,156,614 |
9 |
Oliver Wyman |
604,227 |
13 |
Deloitte |
466,386 |
11 |
KPMG |
384,417 |
6 |
Lake Consulting |
352,252 |
2 |
Willis Towers Watson |
256,352 |
3 |
InnovaCare Services Company |
212,699 |
1 |
Lumeris Healthcare Outcomes |
148,367 |
2 |
Novarest Actuarial Consulting |
134,745 |
3 |
Barry, Dunn, McNeil & Parker |
113,690 |
1 |
The Kilbourne Company |
97,070 |
5 |
Lucerna Health |
59,869 |
2 |
CBIZ |
57,587 |
6 |
RSM US |
53,192 |
2 |
Lee Benefits Consulting |
40,803 |
3 |
Aetna Resources |
38,720 |
1 |
Axene Health Partners |
35,919 |
1 |
Crooks Actuarial Consulting |
34,877 |
4 |
Actuarial Solutions |
31,266 |
2 |
Mulberry Management |
30,453 |
4 |
Source: AM Best data and research
Auditor Firm – 2021 Edition
P/C Loss Reserves (US$000)
Auditor Firm |
P/C Loss
Reserves
(US$000) |
P/C
Count |
PricewaterhouseCoopers |
219,843,320 |
259 |
Ernst & Young |
158,165,545 |
215 |
Deloitte |
157,018,078 |
139 |
KPMG |
119,436,291 |
190 |
Johnson Lambert |
12,809,025 |
132 |
EisnerAmper |
10,537,652 |
12 |
RSM |
7,811,145 |
53 |
Baker Tilly |
5,437,439 |
26 |
Mazars |
5,138,508 |
38 |
BDO |
3,353,683 |
34 |
Crowe |
2,764,945 |
72 |
BKD |
2,682,646 |
38 |
Strohm Ballweg |
2,278,000 |
35 |
Plante Moran |
2,199,684 |
29 |
Grant Thornton |
1,629,884 |
14 |
Dixon Hughes Goodman |
1,306,114 |
24 |
State Auditor General |
1,207,723 |
1 |
Eide Bailly |
1,076,117 |
7 |
MCM |
667,151 |
3 |
Thomas Howell Ferguson |
612,631 |
19 |
Jaynes, Reitmeier, Boyd & Therrell |
529,871 |
13 |
JLK Rosenberger |
509,849 |
30 |
Brown Schultz Sheridan & Fritz |
446,908 |
26 |
Mountjoy Chilton Medley |
435,231 |
3 |
KMH |
434,902 |
7 |
Source: AM Best data and research
Auditor Firm – 2021 Edition
Life Loss Reserves (US$000)
Auditor Firm |
Life Loss
Reserves
(US$000) |
Life Count |
PricewaterhouseCoopers |
1,830,727,481 |
114 |
KPMG |
632,970,081 |
78 |
Deloitte |
605,787,887 |
103 |
Ernst & Young |
593,985,461 |
98 |
Seward & Monde |
24,082,258 |
1 |
BKD |
16,562,157 |
19 |
RSM |
8,921,119 |
16 |
BDO |
8,611,166 |
10 |
Johnson Lambert |
8,433,083 |
14 |
H2R CPA |
5,010,790 |
6 |
Strohm Ballweg |
4,651,233 |
5 |
Larson & Company |
3,967,322 |
6 |
JLK Rosenberger |
3,536,533 |
10 |
Kerber, Eck & Braeckel |
2,908,798 |
14 |
EisnerAmper |
2,435,574 |
6 |
Brown Smith & Wallace |
2,362,589 |
8 |
Eide Bailly |
2,177,469 |
9 |
Ginoli & Company |
1,163,411 |
1 |
Grant Thornton |
1,152,051 |
3 |
Dalby, Wendland & Company |
1,026,769 |
1 |
Hosack, Specht, Muetzel & Wood |
952,080 |
3 |
Frank J. Baker & Company |
891,495 |
2 |
Mazars |
560,412 |
2 |
Lambert Lanza, CPA |
556,671 |
2 |
Crowe |
547,289 |
2 |
Williams-Keepers |
540,045 |
2 |
Baker Tilly |
497,528 |
11 |
Source: AM Best data and research
Auditor Firm – 2021 Edition
Health Loss Reserves (US$000)
Auditor Firm |
Health Loss
Reserves
(US$000) |
Health
Count |
Ernst & Young |
37,325,678 |
178 |
Deloitte |
24,067,777 |
134 |
PricewaterhouseCoopers |
18,820,017 |
121 |
KPMG |
14,760,452 |
100 |
Grant Thornton |
3,024,359 |
21 |
Baker Tilly |
1,399,511 |
18 |
RSM |
1,078,621 |
19 |
Eide Bailly |
953,993 |
14 |
BKD |
930,030 |
19 |
Plante Moran |
817,410 |
34 |
CliftonLarsonAllen |
649,355 |
9 |
Accuity |
579,448 |
3 |
Moss Adams |
286,275 |
8 |
Carr, Riggs & Ingram |
207,089 |
6 |
Kernutt Stokes |
191,904 |
2 |
Dixon Hughes Goodman |
180,371 |
2 |
BDO |
165,715 |
7 |
Centeno Figueroa & Co. |
161,268 |
1 |
Wipfli |
161,224 |
8 |
Marcum |
131,848 |
2 |
McGee, Hearne & Paiz |
116,520 |
2 |
Baird, Kurtz & Dobson |
69,749 |
1 |
Brown Smith & Wallace |
66,655 |
1 |
MCM |
60,229 |
1 |
Baker Newman Noyes |
60,051 |
5 |
Source: AM Best data and research