Best's News


Best’s News & Research Service - March 13, 2002 03:19 PM (EST)

Westfield America Trust Resolves Dispute with Zurich Insurance

    print icon

NEW YORK //BestWire// - Westfield America Trust said it has resolved a dispute with Zurich Insurance over supplementary insurance on the retail component of the World Trade Center.

Last November, Zurich filed a complaint against Westfield in federal court in New York, disputing Westfield's claim for supplementary insurance cover.

As a result of the resolution, court proceedings have been voluntarily dismissed, and Westfield and Zurich agreed that coverage for the World Trade Center loss would go to binding arbitration. If Zurich is found to be obligated to provide the coverage, the obligation won't exceed $55 million, Westfield said.

The dispute centered on the general property insurance Zurich provided, which covers Westfield's "entire shopping center portfolio," according to Westfield, and, the company believes, automatically covered new properties, provided notice of their inclusion in the portfolio was provided to the insurer within 90 days of the acquisition.

Formal notice of Westfield's acquisition of the retail component of the center had been provided to Zurich on Sept. 14, more than a month before the 90-day deadline expired, according to Westfield.

Zurich, however, contended that at no time before Sept. 11 had Westfield arranged for insurance coverage of the new property in its portfolio, said Owens.

With the resolution, both parties also agreed that the Zurich policy, which took effect as part of Westfield's annual renewal of its insurance policies on July 1, 2001, is a general property insurance policy covering Westfield's entire portfolio and contains no terrorism exclusion.

The resolution doesn't negate any of Zurich's claims in its action or any of Westfield's claims in its response to Zurich's action, because Zurich has agreed to drop them, issue Westfield a policy and go forward from there, said Keith Owens, a spokesman for Zurich North America.

Neither side wanted to speculate on the arbitration issue, said Owens. "I know there's an apparatus in place for mutual binding arbitration, but I'm not sure of the details," he said.

The insurance in question is separate from the $3.5 billion "per occurrence" primary insurance policies covering the World Trade Center. Westfield said it had separate primary coverage for its interest in the 99-year lease on the retail component of the center under the $3.5 billion "per occurrence" property and business-interruption insurance policies provided by a consortium of insurance companies regarding Westfield and Silverstein Properties Inc.'s interests in the World Trade Center.

Silverstein, the leaseholder on the World Trade Center, last month reached an agreement with two of the 22 insurers that covered the property, removing the two from the legal battle over whether the destruction of the World Trade Center should be considered one insured loss or two (BestWire, Feb. 25, 2002).

Several lawsuits have been filed to argue the point, with insurers on one side saying the destruction should count as a single insured event, for a combined claim totaling $3.55 billion, while the leaseholder, Silverstein, argues it was caused by two events, triggering two $3.55 billion claims, for a total of $7.1 billion (BestWire, Feb. 8, 2002).

The matter is in dispute largely because insurers had issued binders outlining the coverage provided but hadn't completed the detailed, final contracts when hijackers piloted commercial airliners into the twin towers Sept. 11, destroying them.
(By Fran Matso Lysiak, senior associate editor: lysiakf@ambest.com)



Property And Liability Insurers Property Insurance Business Interruption Insurance September 11 Terrorism New York Reinsurers Litigation Arbitration And Mediation


Latest News

More from Best’s News


Trending


    


2
BEST'S CREDIT RATING ACTION
AM Best Revises Outlooks to Positive for AmTrust Group’s Members
Oct 14, 2026 09:36 AM (EDT)


4
HOMEOWNERS INSURANCE
State Farm, Allstate Plan to Reopen to New Homeowners Business in California
Sep 21, 2026 12:40 PM (EDT)