Best's News


Best’s News & Research Service - March 11, 2004 04:12 PM (EST)

Both Sides Score Points as Twin Towers Trial Winds Up Fifth Week

    print icon

NEW YORK //BestWire// - In the fifth week of testimony in the World Trade Center insurance dispute, attorneys for the insurers got crucial notes admitted as evidence, while drawing out more testimony that appeared to support their position. But attorneys for the twin towers' leaseholders were able to show that underwriting decisions made in the London market might not clearly favor the insurers' case.

Judge Michael Mukasey of U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York agreed to allow post-attack notes taken on Sept. 12, 2001, by Beth Ann Hermann, an executive with GMAC Commercial Mortgage Corp., admitted into evidence-a strong piece of evidence for lawyers representing lead insurer Swiss Reinsurance Co. and the London market insurers involved in the case.

According to attorneys for the insurers, notes taken by Hermann show that, in the first few days after the catastrophe, actions by representatives of the World Trade Center's leaseholders and financiers show an insurance form issued by broker Willis Group Holdings Ltd. (NYSE:WSH) governed most of the coverage, rather than a different form used by Travelers Property Casualty Insurance Co. (NYSE:TAPa).

Which form bound the insurers before the Sept. 11 catastrophe is the critical question before a jury of 12 in Mukasey's court. The Willis form, known as WilProp, provides a definition of "occurrence" that prior court rulings already established would define the twin towers' destruction as a single occurrence. The form submitted by Travelers less than two months before the Sept. 11 terrorist catastrophe leaves the definition of occurrence open.

During the first week of the trial, Swiss Re attorney Barry Ostrager focused on an affidavit containing testimony by Hermann, vice president and director of insurance for GMAC, one of the financiers of the World Trade Center lease, which recounted communications that took place beginning on the morning of Sept. 11 (BestWire, Feb. 12, 2004). Hermann recounted conversations among herself, legal representatives of GMAC, representatives of Harbor Group-which consulted GMAC on insurance matters-and representatives of leaseholder Silverstein Properties Inc.

On Sept. 12, notes taken by Hermann show that Silverstein risk manager Robert Strachan told Harbor Group representatives that the WilProp form provided terms of the insurance coverage. On that same day, Strachan faxed the WilProp manuscript form to the Harbor Group, according to Hermann's notes. Those actions show that Strachan, as Silverstein's risk manager, saw the WilProp form as the governing insurance binder for the World Trade Center, Ostrager argued.

Attorneys for World Trade Center leaseholders Silverstein and Westfield Properties have been arguing that most of 12 insurers involved in the coverage had switched from WilProp to the Travelers form. But lawyers for the insurers contend no such change occurred.

In testimony on March 9, Nicholas Gavin Jones, an underwriter who had been working with Faraday Underwriting Ltd. at Lloyd's in 2001, said he bound Faraday to a coverage layer of $500 million in excess of $1 billion in July 2001. Jones said he had bound coverage on the WilProp form and never had been shown the Travelers form before Sept. 11.

But another Lloyd's underwriter, Neil Chapman of Wellington Underwriting Ltd., admitted under questioning by Silverstein's attorneys that while he had bound coverage on the basis of WilProp in July 2001, the binding agreement-or slip-he signed didn't refer specifically to WilProp. Chapman also said the slip he signed contained a waiver that would give Willis the right to change the wording of the form without consulting Wellington.

Under questioning by Silverstein attorney Peter Hein, Chapman testified that the WilProp form wasn't mentioned specifically in any of the documentation related to the binding of Wellington to the World Trade Center coverage.

In addition to Hermann's notes, Swiss Re attorneys also questioned a Willis broker about the alleged inferiority of the Travelers form for the purposes of Willis' client, Silverstein. Under questioning by Ostrager on March 10, Willis property insurance vice president Edmund F. Harvey said had been asked by a fellow Willis broker on July 18, 2001-the day insurance coverage on the World Trade Center was bound-to review the wording of the Travelers form.

In the following exchange, Harvey-a wording expert who was asked by other Willis brokers to review the wording of the Travelers form-admitted that he found problems with the Travelers form:

Ostrager: You found many aspects where the Travelers form is inferior to the Willis form from your client Silverstein Properties' point of view, correct?

Harvey: Yes.

Later, Harvey testified that he had discussed possible changes to the Travelers form with Travelers representatives but had never discussed the Travelers form with any other bound insurer.

The trial now under way is the first of three possible phases. In the first phase, the jury is to decide which of the insurers involved were bound by the WilProp form, and which, if any, by the Travelers form. In a second phase, any insurers found not to be bound by WilProp would have to state their case that the destruction of the World Trade Center was one event rather than two under the insurance form used-presumably the Travelers form. If that phase were to determine that the insurance form used defined the catastrophe as two events, a third phase would determine how much those insurers should be liable to pay.

Ralph Tortorella, a senior partner with the catastrophic industry practice group of the New York law firm Ropers Majeski Kohn & Bentley, said the subject of the trial isn't an insurance issue per se, but rather an attempt to sort out who agreed to what as the coverage was lined up for the World Trade Center lease. "There is a long line of cases involving adjudicating what was agreed to prior to an event, and how those agreements are interpreted afterward," he said. "This case is different only in the level of complexity-involving multiple layers of financing and coverage."

Tortorella, whose firm isn't involved with the World Trade Center litigation, said it isn't unusual in a complex insurance transaction to have details of the coverage unsettled after the insurers are bound. "Terms might not always be set until after the policy is agreed upon," he said. "This case is going to come down to who is most believable regarding what was agreed to."

It isn't likely that any of the information coming out in the trial about how the World Trade Center coverage was handled would change commercial insurance business practices in any fundamental way, said Tortorella. "Carriers and insureds will want to settle the terms of a policy as soon as possible," he said. "But the World Trade Center coverage is not a traditional scenario. I'm not sure any changes in industry practices are ultimately necessary."

In terms of the World Trade Center case, where the litigants are debating both what was agreed to before Sept. 11 and what was discussed after the event, Tortorella said the evidence of pre-Sept. 11 actions ultimately should weigh more heavily in determining who agreed to what.
(By David Pilla, senior associate editor, BestWeek: David.Pilla@ambest.com)



Property And Liability Insurers Property Insurance Commercial Lines Policy Wording September 11 Policy Forms Policy Changes Reinsurers Policy Exclusions Litigation Claims Policy Limits Brokers


Latest News

More from Best’s News


Trending


    


2
BEST'S CREDIT RATING ACTION
AM Best Revises Outlooks to Positive for AmTrust Group’s Members
Oct 14, 2026 09:36 AM (EDT)


4
HOMEOWNERS INSURANCE
State Farm, Allstate Plan to Reopen to New Homeowners Business in California
Sep 21, 2026 12:40 PM (EDT)


AM Best TV

More Related Company News

To Submit News go to - https://www.ambest.com/bestweek/submitnews.html