Best's News


Best’s News & Research Service - March 25, 2004 03:10 PM (EST)

Silverstein Testimony Highlights Rush to Bind WTC Coverage

    print icon

NEW YORK //BestWire// - Real estate developer Larry Silverstein had his day in court, as attorneys for the leaseholders of the World Trade Center launched their presentations during the seventh week of a federal civil trial to determine the nature of insurance coverage on the twin towers when they were destroyed Sept. 11, 2001.

In testimony before Judge Michael B. Mukasey of U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, Silverstein said there was a rush to get insurance in place on the World Trade Center before a July 19 closing of the lease on the property, in part because the main financier of the lease-GMAC Commercial Mortgage Corp.-wanted to securitize some of the debt related to the transaction and needed to do so before the "August doldrums" in the financial markets. The closing actually took place on July 24, according to Silverstein.

Testimony earlier in the trial had revealed that GMAC insisted that the proper insurance be in place before releasing about $600 million in loans to finance the lease. The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, the World Trade Center's owner, leased the twin towers to Silverstein Properties LLC and Westfield Properties LLC for 99 years, less than two months before the buildings were destroyed. Silverstein Properties leased the office portion of the complex, while Westfield leased the retail area.

"We had to acquire the insurance from insurance companies of a specific quality, in an amount sufficient to serve the needs of the Port Authority and of GMAC, the lender," said Silverstein in his testimony.

Echoing earlier testimony from Bob Strachan, Silverstein Properties' risk manager, who was responsible for obtaining the insurance, Silverstein said he began pushing to get the insurance in place in early July, since the deadline for signing the lease was looming. "I was deeply concerned about meeting the timetable set for the closing, and was keenly aware of the requirement to have insurance in the amount and quality necessitated in time for that closing," Silverstein testified. "And I recall discussing that with Bob and telling him whatever we had to do, we had to do it; we had to get it closed, get it done."

Silverstein admitted that Strachan advised him he could get a better deal with more time. "Bob was concerned that it was not the most efficient way to go, that more time could probably get us better costs, lower costs," he said. "But my concern was timing. That was uppermost in my mind."

The key issue of the trial-the question a jury of 12 must decide-is under which of two forms each of the 12 insurers involved agreed to be bound. The insurers claim they bound under a form developed by Silverstein's broker, Willis Group Holdings Ltd. (NYSE:WSH), known as WilProp 2000. Silverstein contends that most, if not all, of the insurers switched to another form, developed by Travelers Property Casualty Insurance Co. (NYSE:TAPa).

The difference is crucial, since previous court rulings already established that the WilProp form defines the destruction of the World Trade Center as one event, which would cost the insurers an aggregate $3.55 billion in claims. The Travelers form leaves the definition of occurrence less clear. If, as Silverstein contends, the destruction was two events, the total insurance bill would approach $7 billion.

Once the current trial is over, a second phase would require any insurers found not to be bound by WilProp to state their case that the destruction of the World Trade Center was one event rather than two under the insurance form used-presumably the Travelers form. If that phase were to determine that the insurance form used defined the catastrophe as two events, a third phase would determine how much the insurer should be liable to pay.

On that key point, Silverstein testified that he didn't know which form the insurers bound to before Sept. 11.

Following Silverstein, Timothy R. Boyd, a broker with Willis who was in charge of the World Trade Center transaction, was brought back to the stand for testimony under questioning by Silverstein's attorneys. Boyd testified that he had contacted underwriters for the insurers by telephone in July 2001 to tell them he would be replacing the WilProp form with the Travelers form.

Under cross-examination by attorneys for the insurers, who said they had depositions from some of those underwriters in which they said they never spoke with Boyd about the Travelers form, Boyd stuck to his version of events. Boyd also said some of the underwriters bound to coverage without having seen the form to which they were binding.

Boyd had been called to the stand earlier in the trial by attorneys for the insurers, at which time he admitted that the form submitted by Travelers was difficult to work with, and that Willis experts still were in the process of examining it when the World Trade Center was destroyed (BestWire, Feb. 19, 2004).

The courtroom spotlight was on Silverstein earlier in the week, as well, as Mukasey closed a side hearing into a civil contempt charge against the developer by throwing the charge out (BestWire, March 23, 2004). Silverstein had been accused by attorneys for the insurers of defying an order not to comment to the media.

In ruling on the charge, Mukasey said he didn't buy Silverstein's argument that he was unaware a gag order was in place when he spoke at a March 15 press conference at the site of the World Trade Center. Mukasey said Silverstein probably could be found in contempt, but such a finding would be counterproductive.

Mukasey concluded that the comments Silverstein made to the media about the case didn't prejudice the jury. The judge also said he believed that finding Silverstein in contempt "could have a highly prejudicial effect in this case and in future trials, when and if future phases of this litigation are tried."

As he presented his ruling, Mukasey threw in a not-so-subtle threat that any public-relations antics by any party could be used against the offender. Any party seeking to influence the jury by making public statements could lead the court to "go so far as to permit the jury to consider such an effort as evidence that the party in question believes its case is weak," he said.

According to court testimony, Silverstein was taking part in a press conference at "Ground Zero" on plans for rebuilding at the site, when he said the following: "And as you know, we are fighting hard with the insurance companies to achieve the money that is going to be necessary for the rebuilding of downtown...It's an ongoing battle and, as you can understand, they are trying to save the money. We are trying to get them to fulfill the responsibilities that we paid for when we paid the premiums under the policies. Instead of getting insurance, we got ourselves a massive amount of litigation."

Silverstein also said at the press conference that the rebuilding of the site would cost an estimated $12 billion, $5 billion of which would come from the federal government. The other $7 billion, he said, he is counting on coming from the insurers.


(By David Pilla, senior associate editor, BestWeek: David.Pilla@ambest.com)



Property And Liability Insurers Property Insurance Reinsurance September 11 Reinsurers Losses Reinsurance Intermediary Litigation Claims Brokers


Latest News

More from Best’s News


Trending


    


2
BEST'S CREDIT RATING ACTION
AM Best Revises Outlooks to Positive for AmTrust Group’s Members
Oct 14, 2026 09:36 AM (EDT)


4
HOMEOWNERS INSURANCE
State Farm, Allstate Plan to Reopen to New Homeowners Business in California
Sep 21, 2026 12:40 PM (EDT)


AM Best TV

More Related Company News

To Submit News go to - https://www.ambest.com/bestweek/submitnews.html